Women Artists

Female vs. Male Gaze: Suzanne Valadon’s Reclining Nude

Lauren Kraut 5 October 2021 min Read

Female nudes are prevalent throughout art history. There are the ancient mythological goddesses, the Biblical Eves and Susannas, and then there are the female nudes, depictions devoid of any costume either mythological or literal. For those nudes, the formula is basically the same: a beautiful woman lying outstretched on a bed. She is always created by a male artist for the male gaze. Artist Suzanne Valadon brought something different to the nudes: the female gaze.

What nude might come to your mind first? Titian‘s Venus of Urbino?

Or Ingres’ La Grande Odalisque?

suzanne Valadon nude, Back view of a nude white woman laying on a lounge. She wears a westernized version of a turban, holds a fan, and a hookah is at her feet. A blue textured curtain is behind her. This is a westernized fantasy of a woman from a middle eastern culture.
Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres, La Grande Odalisque, 1814, Louvre, Paris, France.

Or perhaps Manet’s Olympia?

suzanne Valadon nude, A white woman reclines on a bed and stares out at the viewer. She has a flower in her hair, a choker, and wears heels. A red curtain is behind her and a cat in a frightened pose at her feet. A Black woman and maid presents her with flowers.
Édouard Manet, Olympia, 1863, Musée d’Orsay, Paris, France.

You would be forgiven if that’s what you thought of as they are considered some of the most important works of art within the art history canon. But what about this one?

Suzanne Valadon, Reclining Nude, 1928, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, NY, USA.
Suzanne Valadon, Reclining Nude, 1928, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, NY, USA.

Meet Suzanne Valadon

It is no coincidence that this work of art of such a realistic nude woman was completed by a woman who lived fully and unapologetically. Suzanne Valadon was born in 1868 and grew up in Montmartre, the center of Parisian art and excitement in the late 19th century. She held a range of jobs beginning at a young age, including trapeze artist, before becoming a model for artists like Pierre-Auguste Renoir and Henri Toulouse-Lautrec, who dubbed her “Suzanne”. As she modeled, she also observed. She learned skills and picked up techniques that she incorporated into her own work. Valadon became good friends with Edgar Degas, who was by then a well-known and popular artist. He essentially validated her as an artist when he became the first person to purchase her work.

With her 1928 Reclining Nude, Valadon reclaimed the female nude and did so on multiple levels.

A black and white photograph of a white woman looking out at the camera. Her dark hair is pulled up and wears a dark colored dress.
Photo of Suzanne Valadon, painter and model. Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

First: The Pose

Titian, Ingres, and Manet controlled how these nude women would appear and deliberately chose to have the women on display for all to see. The female nudes are placed on beds with rumpled sheets as if to underscore their societal roles. There is an imbalanced power dynamic between the artist and subject.

Suzanne Valadon chose something different. Instead of a lithe body stretched out, Valadon folded the model up, limiting and controlling what could be seen. Also, by positioning her like this, she remains contained within the sofa. With her legs pulled up and crossed, her body reacts creating a roll in her stomach. A very natural response, unlike the very unnatural extra vertebrae Ingres decided to include in the Grand Odalisque because it was more aesthetically pleasing. Additionally, if Valadon’s model were to stretch out fully like her counterparts, her legs would dangle over the arms of the couch, which is decidedly unsexy. More like a Saturday morning, not-in-the-mood-to-shower-yet pose.

Second: The Expression

Created for the male gaze, by male artists, the first three women are subjected to the viewer’s once-over. In return, they look back, each with a different expression. Venus with her coquettish head tilt, the Odalisque who glances back to ensure we see her, and defiant Olympia. Valadon’s model seems tired and even a little indifferent. Was this the attitude of the artist, having posed so many times before, coming out in her own painting? Am I projecting the life of the artist too much onto the painting? Perhaps, but whatever the expression is, it does not have the unsubtle allure of the others.

Close up view of the Valadon's
Suzanne Valadon, Reclining Nude, 1928, The Metropolitan Museum of Art,
New York, NY, USA. Detail.

Lastly: Valadon’s Style and Technique

This is not the very clean and precise brushstrokes of Titian and Ingres, though I can (unsurprisingly) see a kinship with Manet. Valadon’s black outline is unsteady yet charmingly underscores the rawness of the painting. The couch has been cropped, its design is indistinct, as if it is unimportant, simply serving as a prop. It is important however – the curves of the couch’s frame match the curves of the woman’s body and the green of the cushions melds perfectly with the model’s skin, hair, and eyes creating a lovely cohesion of color.

It’s always interesting to think about the choices an artist makes. Had she thought about doing a nude like this after all the times she had been a model? Did she and the model share stories about other artists? Commiserate about what it was like to pose for hours on end?

Maybe I am projecting again, but with a painting like this it is hard not to get lost in the possibilities.23


Women Artists

Artsy Advent Calendar: 24 Women Artists to Know

With the festive season approaching, we want to present an advent calendar with 24 women artists to know before Christmas! Explore an array of...

Isla Phillips-Ewen 1 December 2022

Women Artists

Rebecca Solomon: Success and Prejudice in the Victorian World

Rebecca Solomon was a Jewish woman who overcame contemporary prejudices to become a successful artist in mid-Victorian London. In 2022, Princeton...

Catriona Miller 1 December 2022

Nafiseh and Bahareh, Bronze pendant. Women Artists

Hoping Against Hope: Interview with Nafiseh and Bahareh, Iranian Multidisciplinary Artists

Nafiseh and Bahareh are two female multidisciplinary artists. This story began with the discovery that, as artists in Iran, they were unable to sell...

Isla Phillips-Ewen 24 November 2022

Textile artist Sheila Hicks Women Artists

Between Fiber and Color: The Art of Sheila Hicks

Celebrated as one of the biggest names in textile art, Sheila Hicks has a long history of studying ancient techniques and cultures. She has traveled...

Natalia Tiberio 21 November 2022