Masterpiece Stories

Masterpiece Story for All Saints: A Burial at Ornans by Gustave Courbet

Magda Michalska 1 November 2020 min Read

Who nowadays doesn’t appreciate Gustave Courbet‘s striking realism? We all do, but as happens with many geniuses, Courbet was not appreciated by his contemporaries, especially at the beginning of his career. In 1851 he presented this outstanding painting to the French Salon, which in my opinion is a perfect tribute to All Saints: A Burial at Ornans.

“It’s a debut of my principles…”

Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, 1850, Musee d'Orsay, Paris, France.
Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, 1850, Musee d’Orsay, Paris, France.

…said Courbet when exhibiting this work, which he had been working on since 1849. Yet, what did he mean by his ‘principles’? He was referring to Realism, a new innovative direction in painting which he implemented in all of his following works. Realism was about capturing life the way it really was, without idealisation, without escapism. He championed truth, which doesn’t mean that he didn’t imbue his works with meaning. On the contrary, he revealed to his audience that truth can be as symbolic as Jacques-Louis David’s Neoclassicism or Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres’ Orientalism. As he wrote, the purpose of his painting was to:

“(…) translate the customs, the ideas, the appearance of my epoch according to my own appreciation; in a word, to create living art, that is my goal.”

attr. Gustave Courbet, PBS.

A Real Funeral

Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans
Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, 1850, Musee d’Orsay, Paris, France. Detail.

This scene is based on a real life event, the funeral of Courbet’s great-maternal uncle, who was an important member of the small community of the French town of Ornans, located close to the Swiss border. Everyone wanted to pay their respects to him, from the important clergymen, and the mayor, to the butcher and the simple women, even a Masonic judge! How do we know that? Because Courbet painted them all as they really were in life, without any idealisation or masking their features to make them anonymous – anyone from Ornans would recognize them, or even find themselves on the canvas. We can see Courbet’s mother and three sisters (Juliette covers her mouth, Zoé’s face is entirely covered by cloth , and Zélie is on the far right). Moreover, some claim that Courbet even included a portrait of the deceased as if he were alive and a spectator at his own funeral- pay attention to the the gentleman on the extreme left!

Gustave Courbet, Portrait of Oudot, the Artist's Grandfather
Gustave Courbet, Portrait of Oudot, the Artist’s Grandfather, 1847, Dallas Museum of Art, Dallas, TX, USA.

It’s an Offence to Painting

Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans,
Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, 1850, Musee d’Orsay, Paris, France. Detail.

The critics hammered the work for several reasons. Firstly, for its size, (3,15 x 6,68 m) which should have heralded it as a history painting. Which according to the canon should present a solemn historical or religious theme, as only such genre scenes deserved such a grand scale. Courbet instead presented normal people at a funeral, many of which were of a lower class , which outraged the high-class critics and Salon-goers even more, as they couldn’t stand the characters’ ugliness and ordinariness. Secondly, the painting was initially interpreted as anticlerical, because even the clergy were depicted as ugly. Yet later, this interpretation was overturned – in the end, Christ on the cross towers over the entire scene, giving us solace and hope for salvation. Thirdly, viewers didn’t like Courbet’s technique, the thickly layered paint and the dark tones dominated the scene. Somebody said that Courbet painted pictures like somebody blacking their boots…

Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans
Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, 1850, Musee d’Orsay, Paris, France. Detail.

A Burial More Historical then One Would Think

However, if one delved into the painting’s composition and style, one would see a few art historical references which definitely make this painting more noble than expected. The horizontal composition, spread from one edge of the canvas to another, recalls the Dutch 17th century paintings presenting civic guards. Look below, doesn’t it look familiar?

Nicolaes Eliasz. Pickenoy, Banquet of civic guardsmen from the company of captain Jacob Backer and lieutenant Jacob Rogh
Nicolaes Eliasz. Pickenoy, Banquet of civic guardsmen from the company of captain Jacob Backer and lieutenant Jacob Rogh, 1632, Amsterdam Museum, Amsterdam, Netherlands.

The pervasive blacks and deep greens are a reference, too. Courbet looked up to the Spanish masters like Velazquez and Goya, and drew from them inspiration for his own colour palette, which brings out the atmosphere present on All Saints: sadness, nostalgia, melancholy. Yet there is hope, ingeniously suggested by the lighter tones. This hope is life itself, its cyclical nature- life goes on no matter what. I find it very comforting. Talking about loss, I want to close today’s analysis with this video in which contemporary painter Yan Pei-Ming talks about the loss of his mother and A Burial at Ornans.

Yan Pei-Ming shows us his own view on A Burial at Ornans. Musee d’Orsay/Youtube.

Recommended

Frants Henningsen, Funeral, 1883, National Gallery, Copenhagen, Denmark. Detail. Masterpiece Stories

Masterpiece Story: Funeral by Frants Henningsen

Funeral by Frants Henningsen is a Danish masterpiece of emotions. It examines the different psychological reactions to love, loss, and...

James W Singer 23 May 2022

Plate with Arabic Inscription, ca 975-1000, painted and glazed earthenware, Musée du Louvre, Paris, France. Detail. Masterpiece Stories

Masterpiece Story: Plate with Arabic Inscription

Plate with Arabic Inscription is a masterpiece of 10th century Islamic art. It combines minimalism, abstraction, and morality into a beautiful and...

James W Singer 5 May 2022

Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec, At the Moulin Rouge, The Dance, 1890, Philadelphia Museum of Art, Philadelphia, PA, USA. Masterpiece Stories

Masterpiece Story: At the Moulin Rouge, The Dance by Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec

Tonight the Moulin Rouge is bursting at the seams. Men in dark coats and distinguished women dance and converse on the buzzing floor. Each has a...

Ruxi Rusu 29 April 2022

Carl Gustav Carus, Woman on the Balcony, 1824, oil on canvas, Galerie Neue Meister, Dresden, Germany. Detail. Masterpiece Stories

Masterpiece Story: Woman on the Balcony by Carl Gustav Carus

Woman on the Balcony is an intimate portrait of a person lost in thought. There is no action and no obvious story to interpret. However, its quiet...

James W Singer 25 April 2022