fbpx
Connect with us

DailyArtMagazine.com – Art History Stories

Male Homosexuality in Western Art

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, Ecstasy of Saint Francis, c. 1594–1595, Wadsworth Atheneum, Hartford, Connecticut, USA. Wikipedia.

Bodies And Erotic Art

Male Homosexuality in Western Art

Homosexuality is still an underrepresented topic in art historical discourse. Since our magazine stands for inclusivity, we strive to present to you works which might be omitted by a traditional art history course. Last time we had a feature about lesbianism, today it’s time for male homosexuality. Ready?

Ancient Education

8Warren Cup (side B), 5–15 CE, British Museum, male homosexuality art Male Homosexuality in Western Art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Warren Cup (side B), 5–15 CE, The British Museum, London, UK.

Warren Cup, named after its first modern owner, depicts a typical Roman banquet scene: probably an older, or more experienced man, engages in sex with a beardless younger man. Such practices were very common in Roman high society. Older men picked adolescent boys to mentor, and educate them in the art of loving and living. They would grant political influence in return for physical pleasures. Firstly, they would all participate in a feast, eat and drink (from cups like this one), the young boys entertaining the older men with their singing, dancing and recital of poetry (you can see the lyre on the left). Homosexuality was so much part of everyday life to the extent that the Romans didn’t even have a word for it.

Warren Cup (side B), 5–15 CE, British Museum, male homosexuality art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Warren Cup (side A), 5–15 CE, The British Museum, London, UK.

Not So Holy Middle Ages?

Moralised Bible Osterneische Nationalbibliothek, codex Vindbonesis, 2554, c. 1225-45 The British Library, male homosexuality art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Moralised Bible, Osterneische Nationalbibliothek, codex Vindbonesis, 2554, c. 1225-45, The British Library, London, UK.

With the growing power of the Catholic Church, the approach to homosexuality completely changed. Same sex relationships were condemned as violating the natural order decreed by God; which explains why Dante included the ‘sodomites’ in the 7th circle of Hell, together with violent people. In Dante’s day, however, male-male relations, often between a mature man and an adolescent, as in ancient Rome, were very common in Florence. Apart from the eternal fire which was promised to the sinners, earthly penalties ranged from confiscation of property to capital punishment.

The Renaissance Of Sexuality

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, Ecstasy of Saint Francis, c. 1594–1595, Wadsworth Atheneum, Hartford, Connecticut, male homosexuality art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, Ecstasy of Saint Francis, c. 1594–1595, Wadsworth Atheneum, Hartford, Connecticut, USA. Wikipedia.

I had to mention Caravaggio, probably the most famous suspected gay artist. The distinguished Caravaggio scholar Howard Hibbard stated that “Whether Caravaggio was essentially or exclusively homosexual is far from certain” but what is certain is that he inserted many homoerotic hints into his paintings “to tear away [Leonardo’s and Michelangelo‘s] idealizing mask” from male nudes to expose (in such works as Victorious Cupid and St. John the Baptist with a Ram) “the true source”, as Hibbard put it. Michelangelo was gay too, and we have written evidence to support this claim: his love letters and poems to Tommaso dei Cavalieri.

Centuries Undercovers

Léon Choubrac, an illustration from: "La prostitution contemporaine : étude d'une question sociale" by Léo Taxil, 1884, Librairie Populaire, Paris, male homosexuality art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Léon Choubrac, an illustration from: “La prostitution contemporaine : étude d’une question sociale” by Léo Taxil, 1884, Librairie Populaire, Paris, France.

It was really difficult to find any explicit visual evidence for 17th-19th century male homosexual art. As with lesbianism, the influence of the Counter-Reformation, the Inquisition, and later the prudery and Victorian convenance were too overwhelming. Artists had to limit their artistic license to homoerotic hints in history (the figure of Ganymede) or religious painting (the recurring motif of Saint Sebastian), and with, usually underground, distribution of prints. This print illustrates the so-called ‘Molly house’, which was an 18th and 19th century English term for places where homosexual men would meet.

Age of Liberation

Robert Mapplethorpe, Larry and Bobby Kissing, 1979, source: Luna, UMass-Amherst-Art History Image Collection, male homosexuality art
Male Homosexuality in Western Art: Robert Mapplethorpe, Larry and Bobby Kissing, 1979. Luna, UMass-Amherst-Art History Image Collection.

The 20th century witnessed a real revolution. Not only did artists decide to come out of the closet, they also openly spoke about homosexuality in their artworks. This doesn’t mean it was easy. Artists like Will McBride or Robert Mapplethorpe had to fight institutionalized censorship of their art in galleries, as well as having to overcome many legal obstacles. The 1960s was a decisive decade for the entire LGBT movement. The watershed moment was most probably the Stonewall riots of 1969, which took place in the USA. Then, in the 1980s artists felt a social mission to raise awareness about the AIDS crisis, and the continued fight for equal rights. These events marked a shift towards making queer people more visible in mainstream society and culture and less marginalized in public and political discourse.


Discover more Queer art and artists:

Magda, art historian and Italianist, she writes about art because she cannot make it herself. She loves committed and political artists like Ai Weiwei or the Futurists; like Joseph Beuys she believes that art can change us and we can change the world.

Comments

More in Bodies And Erotic Art

  • Bodies And Erotic Art

    History of Medicine in Art. Collection of Artworks at Wellcome Library in London

    By

    If you find any joy and inspiration in our stories, PLEASE SUPPORT DailyArt Magazine with modest donation. We love art history and we want to keep going with writing about it. $5 $10 $25 $50 $100 MONTHLY

  • Bodies And Erotic Art

    Oh, I Do Like To Be Beside the Seaside: Bathing in Art

    By

    With the summer holidays upon us, it seems appropriate to take a small tour through depictions of leisure bathing in art. The package holiday signalled the start of the concept of going away for a break, and we have Thomas Cook in 1841 to thank for...

  • 19th Century

    The Naked Truth About Nudes in Academic Art

    By

    Academicism was a dominant style in European sculpture and painting in the 18th and 19th centuries. It was called so because it was dictated by the French Academy of Art (Académie des Beaux-Arts), which was probably the most influential art school back then. If somebody wanted...

  • Bodies And Erotic Art

    We Are All Summertime Venuses: Beach Bodies in Art

    By

    Venus, who wouldn’t envy her? She is the embodiment of beauty, sexuality, and love. She is perhaps the most often depicted woman in art history. And she was born out of seafoam, what could be more romantic than that? (Now I know why James Bond movies like...

  • Bodies And Erotic Art

    Why is St Sebastian a Gay Icon?

    By

    One may think that Christian saints have little in common with gay culture, but there is an exception to every rule. If you see a handsome guy in his early twenties perforated by arrows, you know it’s St Sebastian, probably the earliest known gay icon. However,...

To Top