Impressionism

Why Should Renoir Be Reconsidered as an Art Master?

Zuzanna Stańska 25 February 2022 min Read

Pierre-Auguste Renoir is considered to be one of the masters of the Impressionist style. However, there are some of Renoir’s paintings that seem to be – to say the least – not that good. Let’s have a look.

We all love Impressionists and usually when we think of their works we see images like this:

Renoir
Claude Monet, Water Lilies, 1916, The National Museum of Western Art, Tokyo.

You know, calm, colorful, and vibrating paintings of water, fields, cities. Subjects that are painted in a broad, rapid style, with easily recognizable brushstrokes and bright colors. The term “Impressionism” comes from a painting by Claude Monet called Impression, soleil levant (Impression, Sunrise), which he exhibited at the Parisian Salon. An art critic saw the exhibition and wrote a review in which he said that all the paintings were just “impressions”.

Among Renoir’s paintings, we don’t expect to see subliminal advertising of Michelin tires:

Renoir
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, The Bathers, 1918-1919, Musée d’Orsay, Paris, France.

or a piece of human flesh put on a salad of seaweed:

Renoir
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Nude On The Grass, 1915, private collection. WikiArt.

or a woman with a lizard face, thigh-size neck, and a hat in the form of a flying saucer:

Renoir
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Lydia Sieligmann, 1917, private collection. Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

or a boy with hands bigger than his head. Did they swell because he’d played Angry Birds on his iPhone for too long? What about his enormous arms? Were they stung by a swarm of bees?

Pierre Auguste Renoir, Jean Renoir Reading, 1908, private collection
Pierre Auguste Renoir, Jean Renoir Reading, 1908, private collection. Pinterest.

This woman from Renoir’s painting is supposed to be wearing a blue blouse – I bet she owned one but it seems she must have left it in the closet on the day Renoir painted her. Renoir was sometimes really horrible with human faces and body proportions. His people usually look like sacks of potatoes glued to tiny heads.

Renoir
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Woman in a Blue Blouse, c. 1906, private collection. WikiArt.

In the United States, there is a movement that requests the removal of all of the literally awful Renoir paintings hanging in the National Gallery in Washington DC. In 2015 they protested in front of a couple of US Museums. Now you know why!

Recommended

Impressionism

Claude Monet in 10 Paintings

We prefer to be sincere; the title is simply intended to catch your attention. Claude Monet painted throughout his life, from adolescence to his...

Tommy Thiange 14 November 2022

Impressionism

Joaquín Sorolla: The Luminosity of the Mediterranean

If you love, like me, summer light, long vacation days, walks on the beach, and lying on the sand with a good book in your hand, these paintings by...

Andra Patricia Ritisan 3 September 2022

Impressionism

Slava Raškaj, The Story of a Deaf Impressionist Watercolorist

In the final years of the 19th century, the art scene in Zagreb, Croatia, was pretty vibrant. The various ideas that circulated among artists...

Lana Pajdas 3 September 2022

Impressionism

Have You Ever Heard About Scottish Impressionists? Here Are the Glasgow Boys

The Glasgow Boys were a group of Scottish Impressionists who placed the city of Glasgow on the artistic scene in the last third of the 19th century.

Andra Patricia Ritisan 30 November 2022