The Art of Law: Legal Drama in Artworks

Maya M. Tola 20 October 2020 min Read

Courtrooms are associated with a wide range of emotions, from hope to anguish, tension to the mundane. While legal drama has tremendous representation on television, it is not as prevalent a theme in traditional artworks, despite the infinite scope for artistic interpretation.

Legal drama in artworks: Pieter Breughel the Younger, The Village Lawyer
Legal Drama in Artworks: Pieter Breughel the Younger, The Village Lawyer, ca. 1621, Museum of Fine Arts, Ghent. Wikimedia Commons.

The Agony of the Legal Process

A set of paintings titled Waiting for the Verdict and Not Guilty by Abraham Solomon are a rare and fascinating depiction of the effect of the legal process. These two paintings are on display at the J Paul Getty Museum in Los Angeles.

Legal drama in artworks: Abraham Solomon, Waiting for the Verdict
Legal Drama in Artworks: Abraham Solomon, Waiting for the Verdict, ca. 1859, J.Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles, USA. Wikimedia Commons.

In the former painting, Solomon has depicted the palpable anxiety of a defendant’s family at the end of the trial. The setting is a rather bleak waiting room with rich wooden paneling and the painting is centered around an old father in insurmountable anguish, surrounded by his distraught family and young grandchildren. It is therefore clear that this has been a difficult time in their lives. A dog watches the old man expectantly as if attempting to console him. There is also visible anger in the eyes of the young wife. The other young woman gazes at the courtroom in the background in anticipation. The open door and the lawyers in conversation at the far end of the hallway indicate the reason behind the state of suspended animation.

Legal drama in artworks: Abraham Solomon, Not Guilty,
Legal Drama in Artworks: Abraham Solomon, Not Guilty, ca. 1859, J.Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles, USA.

In Not Guilty there is the depiction of overwhelming relief upon the evident exoneration of the defendant. Solomon expertly captured the gratitude and the relief in the eyes of the recently acquitted man. He holds on to his wife while his mother and his young child fawn over him. One cannot help but feel great relief for this family and the sweet dog, who, like most dogs, is making sure he is included. The father in the background is pictured offering heartfelt gratitude to his son’s lawyer. The bright lights of the outdoors hint at the new chapter ahead, not just for the man but also for his family. The waiting people in the lobby are an indication of another cycle of wait and hope of people whose fate has been entrusted to the legal process.

The Distrust of Lawyers

Legal drama in artworks: Honoré Daumier, The Skillful Defender
Legal Drama in Artworks: Honoré Daumier, The Skillful Defender, ca. 1808 to 1879, private collection. Sothebys.

Honoré Daumier was a French painter and caricaturist whose work served as a social and political commentary. As a young man, Daumier took a job as a messenger for the law courts in Paris. This exposed him to the complexities and inequities of the legal system and instilled his deep distrust of the law and particularly of the gatekeepers of the legal system. One glance at these works will confirm that the portrayal was not complimentary.

Legal drama in artworks: Honoré Daumier, Two Lawyers Conversing,
Legal Drama in Artworks: Honoré Daumier, Two Lawyers Conversing, ca. 1808 to 1879, The Morgan Library & Museum, New York, USA. Wikimedia Commons.

For example, many of these works depict the lawyers as co-conspirators and perhaps elitists with little-to-no regard for the lives that they impact. Meanwhile, other depictions show the lawyers at work making impassioned pleas on behalf of their clients.

Legal drama in artworks: Honoré Daumier, Three Lawyers,
Legal Drama in Artworks: Honoré Daumier, Three Lawyers, ca. 1855 until 1857, The Phillips Collection, Washington DC, USA. Wikimedia Commons.

The Art of Courtroom Illustrations

The art of courtroom illustration dates as far back as the 19th century. News outlets and television networks commissioned artists to capture legal proceedings in an era when judges did not permit cameras in the courtroom to avoid distractions or preserve the privacy of litigants.

Legal drama in artworks: Butch Krieger, Illustration Chi Mak Flanked by her Attorneys during her sentencing,
Legal Drama in Artworks: Butch Krieger, Illustration Chi Mak Flanked by her Attorneys during her Sentencing, ca. 1983. Wikimedia Commons.

Some courtrooms allowed artists to create their sketches as they perceived them, while other artists would rely on working from their memory. Talented artists skillfully rendered intense moments of legal drama as well as mundane events of life in courtrooms within minutes!

Legal drama in artworks: Marcia Danitz, Sketch of T. Markus Funk, Joseph Lombardo and Frank Calabrese Sr. during the Family Secrets Trial.
Legal Drama in Artworks: Marcia Danitz, Sketch of T. Markus Funk, Joseph Lombardo and Frank Calabrese Sr. during the Family Secrets Trial. ca. 2005. Wikimedia Commons.

Although camera usage has been permitted in state and federal courts since 1977 and the role of the courtroom sketch artist has undoubtedly diminished, the practice endures today and the Library of Congress website preserves works from notable trials.


If you’re looking for beautiful masterpieces to beautify your wall – here is the DailyArt 2021 calendar for you!

Recommended

Ancient Greece

Alexander the Great and His Mermaid Sister in Greek Folklore

There is no need for a long introduction to Alexander the Great’s place in history; he is one of the most famous military leaders and he has...

Errika Gerakiti 29 March 2023

Ancient Rome

Khaled al-Asaad — The Hero of Palmyra

Five years ago on August 18, 2015, the world-renowned Palmyran expert Khaled al-Asaad was brutally murdered by the Islamic State (ISIS) after weeks...

Maya M. Tola 18 August 2020

Abstract Expressionism

Joseph Beuys at BASTIAN Gallery

Joseph Beuys (1921 – 1986), currently on display at BASTIAN gallery, was a controversial German artist, whose work regularly caused public...

Isla Phillips-Ewen 1 October 2019

Brak kategorii

Protest at Andy Warhol From A to B and Back Again—with Sage

An innocent visit to the Whitney Museum of American Art in the West Village of New York City on Sunday, December 9, turned into something more. The...

Howard Schwartz 15 December 2018