Connect with us

DailyArtMagazine.com – Art History Stories

This Looks Out of Tune!? Finding Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings

Wassily Kandinsky, Composition VII, 1913, State Tretyakov Gallery, Moscow.

Music

This Looks Out of Tune!? Finding Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings

Russian artist Wassily Kandinsky painted some of the most beautiful pieces of art, in a style that is instantly recognisable. The flurry of lines, colours and shapes, demonstrates an ability to enchant art lovers without representing any recognisable forms, a hallmark of his oeuvre or creative output. Kandinsky felt that his style was “dissonant”, especially in terms of colour, a musical term that relates to notes that clash when played together or next to each other. Whilst the featured example, his Composition VI, is chaotic, wild, striking, energetic, discontinuous, and so on – my own opinion is that it is visually incredible and not at all dissonant, like ‘popping candy’ for your eyes!

Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings
Wassily Kandinsky, Composition VI, 1913, Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, Russia.

The painting demonstrates so much of Kandinsky’s positive window into pre-war Modernism or Expressionism; were it not for the effects of the two world wars on the mind sets of Western European artists it seems obvious that Modernism would be quite different owing to the disillusion and devastation that had soured the atmosphere during this time.

Wassily Kandinsky, Port. Odessa, 1898, Tretyakov Gallery, Moscow, Russia.

Kandinsky’s early paintings are equally but entirely different in their beauty. Odessa, Port (1898) is an example from his early paintings that shows his connection with Impressionism; one would not be surprised if we were told that it belonged to Monet, but the colour composition of the water in the bottom right hints enough to understand where his technique would end up.  His focus on the effects of the light reflecting off the water and the way he renders the image of the boats, would also not look out of place amongst a collection of Turner paintings either. The key ingredient to their methods is the use of colour; in each case the colours are not unrealistic, they are often in fact the most realistic representation of a scene at a fixed point during the day. A lesser artist will often paint a more prescribed image than the one in each of these pieces. What each artist wanted was to bring originality to their colour compositions in a way that is realistic, beautiful and reflects the vividness of colour encountered when the scientific properties of light meet the imagination of truly great artists.

Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings
Arnold Schoenberg, The Red Gaze, 1910.

In 1911 Kandinsky felt compelled to write a letter to Arnold Schoenberg, the essence being that he felt a connection with the artistic aims of the Austrian composer; in particular Kandinsky liked the idea that his music was attempting to communicate an entirely new language – one that spoke from the soul and embraced dissonance:

In your works, you have realised what I, albeit in uncertain form, have so greatly longed for in music.  The independent life of the individual voices in your compositions, is exactly what I’m trying to find in my paintings.

W. Kandinsky

Schoenberg’s music can be incredibly difficult to listen to as it contradicts many of our musical expectations. It is not necessarily loud or abrasive, it does not contain foul words or imagery, it instead consists of dissonant notes that sit awkwardly with each other; much like playing adjacent black and white notes on the piano, changing our anticipations each time a new note arrives. It is the musical equivalent of speaking a new language that makes no sense, because we have never used these combinations of words before.

Wassily Kandinsky. Impression III (Concert), 1911, Lenbachhaus, Munich Germany.

Kandinsky encounters Schoenberg’s music at a concert in 1911, the piece is Klavierstück op. 33a, an atonal piece of piano music that prompts Kandinsky to go home and paint his Impression III (Concert) (1911). Both artist and musician wanted to communicate through a new language, one that expressed their ideas through unrecognisable elements.

J.W. Goethe, symmetric colour wheel with associated symbolic qualities, 1809. Wikimedia Commons.

The latter part of the 19th century had been about using colours that were in harmony with each other, based on the theories of Goethe, Chevreul, and Hayter, finding application in the paintings of the Impressionists and Post-Impressionists. Kandinsky used dissonance in the relations of his colours, intending to turn these colour theories on their head. He instead intended to create ‘compositions’, as he called them – paintings to us, which clashed these colours together in a form of visual dissonance. Artists such as Seurat, of the Post-Impressionist movement, pioneered the ‘chromo-luminism’ method (Pointillism to you and I), where each spot of colour had a complimentary colour from the opposite side of the colour wheel (above); to create a brighter more vibrant image. It was Kandinsky’s idea to contradict this method to his own ends.

This quote below is an excerpt from Kandinsky’s first letter to Schoenberg, which led to many more still, as each shared their thoughts on a new musical and artistic language. Schoenberg thought of himself as an artist also, painting pictures such as The Red Gaze (1910, pictured above) and many more self-portraits and other types of imagery, where his musical desire to express dissonance also appeared in his paintings. This is a well-tread discussion amongst musical academics, as the dis-functionality in the painting is often married with the difficulty in listening to his music. What the letters between Kandinsky and Schoenberg reveal is a desire for order, system and form.  Kandinsky writes,


‘Construction is what has been so woefully lacking in the paintings of recent times, and it is good that it is now being sought.  But I think differently about the type of construction.’

Wassily Kandinsky
Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings
Wassily Kandinsky. Farbstudie: Quadrate mit konzentrischen Ringen, 1913, Lenbachhaus, Munich, Germany.

It is easy to keep coming back to the simplicity of a painting like Squares with Concentric Circles (1913, above) as a “go to” visualisation of Kandinsky’s methods, his ideals and an embodiment of ‘Abstract Art’. The painting contains many of his key traits such as geometric shapes and vivid colours, as well as simplicity that either focuses the message or confuses those who see art as only a means of capturing an image. Like Schoenberg, Kandinsky wanted to speak through original means, using a new kind of order. This is much like having a fresh new idea but not wanting it to come out sounding like the same old thing – much like politics! This opposes any idea that Schoenberg created music that was chaotic or random; on the contrary, he just did not want his music to sound the same as his predecessor’s.


Both artist and composer wanted to create beauty in their art forms, but not featuring the same typical forms as those in Kandinsky’s early works: a boat, a river, the sky, indeed almost none of his paintings contained human forms except for odd ones like the mysterious Blue Rider (Der Bleu Reiter, 1903).

Dissonance in Kandinsky’s Paintings
Wassily Kandinsky, Der Blaue Reiter, 1911. Artsy, Public Domain.

By discarding conventional forms such as boats and trees Kandinsky was able to find beautiful expression through geometry, colour and musically inspired counterpoint. Whereas Schoenberg’s music is often thought of as difficult to palette, the uniqueness of Russian artist Kandinsky’s colours and lines are illuminating, bright and appealing to the eye. Whereas so much of the discussion around Kandinsky focuses on the Der Blaue Reiter Group, the Bauhaus, his former life as a law graduate, and often just Concentric Circles, this discussion shows his evolution from copy-cat Impressionist to a defining Modernist of an era; creating a new artistic means of expression that is bold and beautiful, bringing a new definition to the term ‘dissonance’.

          

Craig Wakerley is a musician with a love of visual art. He is currently working on a thesis that compares the processes in music and art to find common techniques for representing up, down, far, near, colour and more specific techniques like chiaroscuro and Pointillism.

Comments

More in Music

  • René Magritte, The Lovers II, 1928, Museum of Modern Art, New York Rene magritte Lovers rene magritte Love René Magritte, The Lovers II, 1928, Museum of Modern Art, New York Rene magritte Lovers rene magritte Love

    Love Story

    René Magritte: Lovers in Separation

    By

    Now, while we are all being asked to practice social distancing, you have probably been bombarded with the paintings of lovers by René Magritte. Magritte’s surreal style is unmistakable, his wit is well-known but his depictions of love and lovers are quite disturbing. These beautiful (and...

  • 20th century

    The Window and the Pitchfork: The Story Behind Wood’s American Gothic

    By

    Under the blue sky of Iowa, a man and a woman stand solemnly in front of their house. They are farmers as suggested by their clothing and the pitchfork the man is holding. This is Wood’s American Gothic, one of the most iconic artworks in American...

  • 20th century

    10 Things You Must Know About Tamara de Lempicka

    By

    Tamara de Lempicka was many things: a successful artist, a society darling, an expat. She knew how to create interest in herself and capitalize on it. She was an artist and a celebrity at the same time. You may say she was way ahead of her...

  • 20th century

    Once Upon a Time in Moscow: Pertsov’s House, a Russian Terem Amidst Modern Buildings

    By

    This building from the art-nouveau era is a sight for sore eyes! Pertsov’s house is an interesting example of Russian classical folk influences combined with 20th century architecture. Pertsov’s Apartment House is one of the most famous buildings in Moscow. The house is an embodiment of...

  • 20th century

    5 Modern Women Artists to Know

    By

    When we think of modern women artists, certain names immediately come to mind. For instance, anyone can name Frida Kahlo, and the more well-read will even mention names like Leonora Carrington or Hilma af Klint. However, the art of women who lived and created in the...

To Top

Just to let you know, DailyArt Magazine’s website uses cookies to personalise content and adverts, to provide social media features and to analyse traffic. Read cookies policy