Review

Spellbound by Marcel, But Not Really About Him

Alexandra Kiely 21 March 2022 min Read

Ruth Branden’s Spellbound by Marcel: Duchamp, Love, and Art (New York: Pegasus Books, Ltd., 2022) is a new book about the New York City-based circle of Marcel Duchamp. However, it’s not very much about Duchamp, and even less about his art.

Spellbound by Marcel

Spellbound by Marcel follows the antics of Marcel Duchamp and the circle of avant-garde thinkers he befriended while waiting out World War I in New York City. Ostensibly, it’s about the people who fell in love with Duchamp in one way or another, but that’s really more of a jumping-off point than a real focus. In truth, the book isn’t really about Duchamp, since the narrative often takes extensive detours away from him. It’s even less about his art; if anything, the author consistently de-emphasizes art’s role in Duchamp’s life and only glosses over his later artistic fame. Instead, the book is really about the many wild love affairs that took place amongst Duchamp’s New York friends.

Five-Way_Portrait_of_Marcel_Duchamp,_21_June_1917,_New_York_City

Five-way Portrait of Marcel Duchamp, June 21, 1917, New York City, 1917. Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

A Little Light Reading

Spellbound by Marcel makes for some enjoyable reading. The revolving door of affairs, breakups, betrayals, and wild avant-garde stunts is quite juicy, making this book the perfect thing to read over spring break. It’s also impressively researched, judging by the profusion of primary and secondary sources referenced at the bottom of each page. Braden speaks with the authority that comes from intimate familiarity with the key players’ own words about their lives. Despite this, the tone is quite readable – more conversational than scholarly. All those sources never burden the narrative.

Entertaining and well-supported though it may be, I’m not sure I really gained much from reading Spellbound by Marcel. I didn’t learn anything new or gain any meaningful insight into Duchamp’s life, personality, or art. As mentioned before, neither gets as much of the focus as the book’s title and blurb would suggest. In fact, a large part of the narrative dwells on a relationship only tangential to Duchamp – the brief love affair between his friends, the American artist and writer Beatrice Wood (1893-1998), and the French writer/opportunist/sex addict Henri-Pierre Roché (1879-1959).

In fact, Duchamp becomes rather scarce for much of part two, by far the longest section of the book. He does reappear after that, though, in time to have some questionable adventures in matrimony in the years following World War One. Although the book follows Duchamp and some of his friends through to the ends of their lives, this later material receives a rather summary treatment. This is unfortunate because those are the years in which several of them – Wood in particular – actually achieved the greatest artistic success.

Marcel_Duchamp,_Francis_Picabia,_and_Beatrice_Wood_at_the_Broadway_Photo_Shop,_NYC,_1917

Some of the book’s main players: Marcel Duchamp, Francis Picabia, and Beatrice Wood on Coney Island in 1917. Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

It’s All Fun and Games… or Is It?

Duchamp ran with an uninhibited, free-thinking set, where everybody supposedly engaged in free love without emotional consequences. However, one gets the impression that in actuality, it only worked that way for a few people, mostly the men. Duchamp and particularly Roché looked pretty callous, at best, in their treatment of the myriad women in their lives.

To be fair, they do come across as eager to respect and collaborate with women professionally. They also seem like they were pretty decent friends to the women they weren’t sleeping with, and I didn’t get the sense that Marcel or any of his friends was at all abusive. However, almost all the men in the story felt quite comfortable double (and even triple) timing their girlfriends, stringing one along while gallivanting with another, and just expecting everyone to be okay with it.

Without openly judging them, Brandon sets out their behavior and lets it speak for itself. But thanks to her deep dive into the aforementioned first-person sources, we get to hear their own words about these relationships. This perspective does them no favors, at least in the selections the author chose to share with us. Brandon also doesn’t seem inclined to judge any of the group’s other unconventional behavior, either for good or for ill. Instead, she gives readers the refreshing opportunity to form their own opinions about these often-perplexing people.

Women Who Deserve Better

Katherine Dreier 1910

Katherine Sophie Dreier, 1910. Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

I have issues with how Duchamp and his friends sometimes treated women, but I don’t like how Brandon treats female characters, either. On multiple occasions, I found her prose to come across as downright dismissive towards some of the women in the narrative, particularly those who did not participate in the avant-garde sexcapades.

Most egregiously, Brandon repeatedly characterizes some of Duchamp’s friends, specifically the Stettheimer sisters and Katherine Dreier, as rich, middle-aged hangers-on. She literally classifies them under the heading “Marcel’s Wealth, Middle-Aged Lady Friends” in the opening list of characters, as though they weren’t important modernist artists and thinkers in their own rights. Their middle-aged status crops up almost every time these women appear, usually alongside some comment about Dreier’s broad girth and suggestion that these ladies were somehow unworthy of Marcel’s time. This is just disappointing, especially coming from a 21st-century female author. Both art collector Dreier and the much-celebrated Stettheimers deserve much better.

I genuinely enjoyed reading Spellbound by Marcel, albeit in a superficial sort of way. It’s a fun enough read if you like avant-garde antics and Gossip Girl-worthy tales of complicated romantic entanglements. But if you’re craving interesting content about Marcel Duchamp and his work, I would suggest looking elsewhere.

Spellbound by Marcel: Duchamp, Love, and Art by Ruth Brandon was released on March 1, 2022, by Pegasus Books.

Recommended

Review

A New Guidebook for Artists and Art Lovers: The Oil Painter’s Color Handbook

As someone who spends a lot of time thinking about paintings, I still often lose sight of how they’re actually made. Theoretical and historical...

Louisa Mahoney 21 November 2022

Niki de Saint Phalle surrounded by her sculptures painting Le Monde, c. 1981. Photograph by Laurent Codominas © 2010 Niki Charitable Art Foundation. Courtesy of Opera Gallery. Detail. Review

Find Paradise with Niki de Saint Phalle: Paradis Retrouvé in Opera Gallery

This week marks the birthday of Niki de Saint Phalle, the Franco-American artist who died in 2002. To celebrate the occasion, I visited a new...

Louisa Mahoney 29 October 2022

Olafur Eliasson - Under the weather, 2022 Review

Olafur Eliasson’s Investigation of Time and Space at Palazzo Strozzi in Florence

Nel tuo tempo (In your time), which recently opened in Florence, is Icelandic-Danish Olafur Eliasson’s largest exhibition and first solo show in...

Carlotta Mazzoli 3 November 2022

Review

Decorate Your Coffee Table with Prime, Art’s Next Generation

A corporate catalog of contemporary artists and art-world snobs or a colorful compendium of compelling creators? In this review of Prime. Art’s...

Isla Phillips-Ewen 7 November 2022