Review

Susie Barstow’s First-Ever Biography: This Is Her Moment

Emily Snow 11 May 2023 min Read

During her lifetime, the American landscape artist Susie Barstow (1836-1923) was nationally renowned and commercially successful. So why don’t we know more about her now? Author Nancy Siegel addresses this question in Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School. This new book rightfully—and delightfully—reinstates Barstow in the male-dominated legacy of American landscape art.

 

Susie Barstow: Book cover of Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School by Nancy Siegel, published by Lund Humphries, 2023. Courtesy of the publisher.

Book cover of Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School by Nancy Siegel, published by Lund Humphries, 2023. Courtesy of the publisher.

Barstow’s First Biography

Coinciding with the 100th anniversary of the artist’s death, Susie Barstow’s first-ever biography is the showcase she deserves. The book is complete with enchanting details, fascinating historical context, abundant primary sources, and over 100 paintings, sketches, and photographs, most of which have been in private collections until now.

Published by Lund Humphries, Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School is indeed an important addendum to the traditional narrative of American landscape painting. Siegel also successfully immerses readers in the compelling life story of an independent woman who dared to paint landscapes and climb mountains—often simultaneously—in 19th-century America.

The time is long past due to bring forward this accomplished artist’s story to illuminate an expanded history of the Hudson River School. This is her moment.

Nancy Siegel

Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School, p. 15.

Susie Barstow: Photograph of Susie M. Barstow in her studio, c. 1900, family archives of Elisha Blossom Barstow via Hawthorne Fine Art.

Photograph of Susie M. Barstow in her studio, c. 1900, family archives of Elisha Blossom Barstow via Hawthorne Fine Art.

Susie Barstow: Accomplished Artist and Mountaineer

The 19th-century confines of gender and geography were no match for Susie Barstow, who was known to hike in hemmed skirts and sketch in situ during snowstorms. Barstow was especially drawn to mountains, from the Catskills of her home state of New York to far-flung corners of the world. She famously summited over 100 mountain peaks during her lifetime.

Barstow’s career spanned six decades wherein she relentlessly explored the natural world and successfully exhibited and sold landscape paintings. Her widely-circulated obituary referred to Barstow as a “prominent landscape artist, whose paintings won her wide renown.”1

Susie M. Barstow finally re-establishes Barstow as a “prominent landscape artist” in the history of American landscape painting. As a follower of the Hudson River School, Barstow rendered her direct observations of nature, along with their emotional and spiritual resonance, across an impressive oeuvre of landscape paintings, watercolors, and sketches. Many of these works are now publicly accessible for the first time thanks to Siegel’s biography.

She is exceedingly fond of unbeaten tracks and of studying Nature in unconventional ways.

The Brooklyn Daily Eagle, Sunday, 15 October, 1899.

Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School, p. 142.

Susie Barstow: Susie M. Barstow, Landscape (In the Woods), 1865, collection of Elizabeth and Alfred Scott via Thomas Cole National Historic Site.

Susie M. Barstow, Landscape (In the Woods), 1865, collection of Elizabeth and Alfred Scott via Thomas Cole National Historic Site.

Redefining the Hudson River School

The Hudson River School is considered to be the first bona-fide American art movement in the Western canon. It has primarily been associated with the grandiose, transcendental landscape paintings of Thomas Cole and other white male artists. Despite her relative obscurity today, Susie Barstow was celebrated for uniquely engaging with and contributing to the burgeoning Hudson River School movement.

The likes of Cole were famous for exhibiting dramatic, larger-than-life canvases—but these paintings weren’t accessible to most audiences. Susie Barstow found creative fulfillment and made an independent living by recognizing the growing demand for smaller, yet equally striking, American landscape paintings.

Susie Barstow’s personal observations of the natural world were a key selling point of her work. In fact, Siegel demonstrates how local and national press met the demand for news regarding Barstow’s frequent forays into nature and the new paintings with which she returned. Barstow’s easel-sized landscapes were no doubt as influential as Cole’s showstoppers in popularizing the iconic Hudson River School movement.

Susie Barstow: Book spread from Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School by Nancy Siegel, published by Lund Humphries, 2023. Courtesy of the publisher.

Book spread from Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School by Nancy Siegel, published by Lund Humphries, 2023. Courtesy of the publisher.

Centering Susie Barstow’s Life and Art

Looking at the familiar history of American landscape painting through the less familiar lens of Susie Barstow is illuminating and refreshing. Her story is unique, and her life’s work is clearly worthy of the consideration it receives in her first biography.

Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School naturally addresses how Barstow’s gender and other cultural constructs impacted both her lived experience and her exclusion from history books. However, Siegel does much more than retroactively insert Barstow into an established canon. Rather, Barstow’s dynamic life story, unique perspective, and luminous landscape paintings take center stage in the narrative.

Through Siegel’s comprehensive research, engaging storytelling, and curation of illustrations, Susie Barstow seemingly speaks for herself, reminding us of her rightful place in the legacy of American landscape painting—and challenging us to reimagine that legacy altogether.

Susie Barstow: Susie M. Barstow, Fall in the White Mountains, 1872, private collection. Hawthorne Fine Art.

Susie M. Barstow, Fall in the White Mountains, 1872, private collection. Hawthorne Fine Art.

More About Susie Barstow’s Biography

Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School is part of publisher Lund Humphries’ Northern Lights series, which includes a fascinating range of topics and artist surveys under the expansive scope of Northern art. Author Nancy Siegel, a Professor of Art History and Culinary History at Towson University, expertly and engagingly presents her knowledge of and passion for American landscape art in Susie M. Barstow.

Barstow’s first-ever biography also coincides with the first-ever retrospective of her paintings, with Siegel as a curator. A traveling exhibition that centers Susie Barstow and aims to expand and challenge the legacy of American landscape art, Women Reframe American Landscape, opens in May 2023 at the Thomas Cole Historic Center, located amidst the Catskill Mountains Barstow so loved.

 

Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School can be purchased on the publisher’s website

Footnotes

1
  1. Susie M. Barstow: Redefining the Hudson River School by Nancy Siegel, 2023, p. 15.

Recommended

Review

Vitamin C+: The Art of Collage in Phaidon’s New Book 

Phaidon’s Vitamin C+ Collage in Contemporary Art is the latest addition in the Vitamin series and will introduce you to everything you need to know...

Carlotta Mazzoli 22 May 2023

Review

Phaidon’s Vitamin T: A Complete Guide to Textile Art

Gathering the work of over 100 artists, Vitamin T: Threads and Textiles in Contemporary Art is the most comprehensive survey of artists currently...

Carlotta Mazzoli 13 April 2023

See What You're Missing cover Review

Book Review: See What You’re Missing

See What You’re Missing: New Ways of Looking at the World Through Art, a new book by UK art expert and former Tate director Will Gompertz,...

Alexandra Kiely 20 April 2023

Friendship, Nicole Tersigni, Friends To Keep In Art And Life, 2022 Review

Nicole Tersigni: Friends to Keep in Art and Life

Pairing classical paintings from art history with incisive humor, Nicole Tersigni explores female friendship in all its magical and hilarious guises.

Candy Bedworth 12 January 2023