Connect with us

DailyArtMagazine.com – Art History Stories

George Washington’s Triumphant Return To America – See His Modello At The Frick

Left: Antonio Canova, Modello for George Washington, 1818, Gypsotheca e Museo Antonio Canova, Possagno, Photo: Fabio Zonta; Right: Gilbert Stuart, George Washington, 1795, The Frick Collection, New York

NYC Art Critic

George Washington’s Triumphant Return To America – See His Modello At The Frick

George Washington, the father of the United States, died on December 14, 1799, at the age of 67. Sixteen years later, Washington began posing for a posthumous portrait by the leading neoclassicist sculptor of the day, Antonio Canova.

Thomas Jefferson, who had never met the artist and had never seen the sculptures of the artist in person, recommended Canova for the job. In 1821, the finished marble sculpture was sent to the United States, where it was proudly displayed in the State House in Raleigh, North Carolina. This was the only commission that Canova had ever had in the U.S.

Unfortunately, less than ten years later, a raging fire destroyed the marble sculpture, burning most of it beyond recognition. Only remnants of Canova’s great work survived. By this time, in 1931, both Antonio Canova and Thomas Jefferson were deceased. And so one of the great treasures of early American art was gone forever.

Antonio Canova, Modello for George Washington, 1818, Gypsotheca e Museo Antonio Canova, Possagno, Fondazione Canova onlus, Possagno; Photo: Fabio Zonta

However, Canova had made a “full-size preparatory model” of the statue, called a modello. The modello is the best indication we have of what the finished marble sculpture looked like. The Frick Collection, located on Fifth Avenue in New York City, within a mile of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, is displaying this modello, along with preparatory sketches in clay, sculptures by Jean-Antoine Houdon and Giuseppe Ceracchi, a painting of George Washington by Gilbert Stuart, and related drawings, in an exhibit that is on view through September 23, 2018.

The second room of the exhibition “Canova’s George Washington”, The Frick Collection, New York

The modello is seen in its own room. The Frick explained that it wanted to replicate the feeling of the marble statue being on display in the State House. The ceiling of the State House was lower than the ceiling of this room in the Frick (which is one of the reasons why George Washington is seated instead of standing; a standing statue would have been too big for the State House).

George Washington by Canova

Gilbert Stuart, George Washington, 1795, The Frick Collection, New York

George Washington looks majestic, dressed in Roman clothes, not the George Washington I’ve come to expect from looking at Gilbert Stuart paintings. Canova did not use any of the Gilbert Stuart paintings of George Washington for reference; the painting that is part of this exhibit is there to emphasize this point.

George Washington by Canova

Jean-Antoine Houdon, Life Mask of George Washington, 1785, The Morgan Library & Museum, Gift of J. P. Morgan, Jr.,1924, The Pierpont Morgan Library, New York

Canova also did not use a sculpture of George Washington’s face by Jean-Antoine Houdon as a reference. Thomas Jefferson believed that a bust by Giuseppe Ceracchi was a better likeness than not only the Houdons, but also the familiar Gilbert Stuart portraits that I’ve associated with Washington since early childhood. Stuart’s version of Washington looks older, less athletic, and overly serious by comparison. Even with this quest for a more perfect likeness, Canova appears to have made Washington’s nose is little longer than it really was shown elsewhere, and a little more Roman, more in keeping with the appearance of the Ceracchi bust than with the Houdon face. Houdon softened Washington’s features more than Ceracchi had.

Giuseppe Ceracchi, George Washington, ca. 1791–92, Nantes Métropole, Musée d’arts © Nantes Métropole – Musée d’arts de Nantes, Photographie: C. CLOS

My first inclination was to look at this modello of George Washington from my 20th or 21st-century perspective. I wanted to walk around the sculpture and watch it move in space. I wanted to see the hand of the artist in the plaster, and I wanted to learn more about George Washington by gazing into his eyes. What does Canova notice about George Washington that I have never seen or felt before?

Taking this approach would have been a mistake. This sculpture was made during the time of neoclassicism. Neoclassicism has a completely different aesthetic from that of my modern sensibility, and to view this model through my modern lens would have done this work of art a grave disservice.

I realized that I needed to travel in the opposite direction. Instead of bringing Canova into the 21st-century kicking and screaming, I needed to bring myself back in time, back to 1821, back to when the influence of Johann Joachim Winckelmann was unrivaled throughout the art world. Winckelmann was, among many things, an art historian whose influential writings captured the spirit and energy of neoclassicism. Neoclassicism strove to recreate ancient Greek art. This was done by the idealization of form and content. A neoclassical artist is more concerned with expressing beauty than he is in accurately portraying the world around him. And the neoclassical artist aspires to idealize more than the beauty of his subject; he wishes to also idealize his subject’s strength of character.

Canova’s George Washington is a man of honor. He is a man who is so noble that he chose to give up his power when he very easily could have held on to it. Washington was a modern day Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus, another man who wielded great power, yet also gave it all up to live in retirement on his farm. Cincinnatus was a Roman dictator and he had just won a war. In Washington’s case, he not only gave up the power of the American presidency by refusing to run for a third term in office; years earlier, he had also resigned from the United States army. This is why Washington was dressed as he was, to make the similarity to Cincinnatus that much more apparent. In its description, the Frick quotes the painter John Trumball, who wrote in the year 1784:

Tis a Conduct so novel, so inconceivable to People, who, far from giving up powers they possess, are willing to convulse the Empire to acquire more.

Canova is idealizing George Washington, making him a symbol of what he represents instead of showing him as he really is. Gilbert Stuart never painted George Washington like this. Washington has never looked more powerful or more athletic or more muscular. In the world of 1821, I look at this modello and feel proud that such a great man had been there to lead us. He makes me proud to be an American and to follow his spiritual lead. George Washington is like a Greek god, but without the fatal flaws of a Greek god. Washington is seen preparing his farewell address. As the tablet he is holding indicates, the year is 1796.

George Washington by Canova

Sir Thomas Lawrence, Antonio Canova, 1815–19, Gypsotheca e Museo Antonio Canova, Possagno, Fondazione Canova onlus, Possagno

Neoclassicism is not supposed to be about emotion, but sometimes emotion sneaks its unassuming head into the conversation anyway. The emotion, in this case, comes from an idea of who George Washington is, and the brilliant decision to convey who he is by comparing him to another great leader from another time. Once I understood what Canova had set out to do, I was moved by this plaster sculpture far more than I would have expected. And suddenly, the neoclassical perspective was the perfect approach to express a profound truth about one of the most fascinating and revered people in the brief history of the United States.

Find out more:

May 23, 2018 to September 23, 2018,
The Frick, New York

Howard Schwartz is an artist, writer, cartoonist, calligrapher and art historian who recently was interviewed for the documentary ‘In Celebration of Chaim Soutine’s 125th Anniversary.’ Please visit www.soutine.co to see the documentary and share his passion for Soutine. Howard also illustrated the book ‘Caddie Tales for the 99 Percenters,’ available on Amazon. He enjoys good vegetarian restaurants, art museums, art movies, and learning new things. His website is www.howardschwartzart.com.


More in NYC Art Critic

  • Monumental Paintings of Lucian Freud Monumental Paintings of Lucian Freud


    The Monumental Paintings of Lucian Freud


    The paintings in the Lucian Freud: Monumental exhibition in Acquavella Gallery on the Upper East Side in New York City are monumental in many ways, and the catalogue that accompanies the exhibition feels monumental as well. Freud originally painted with fine sable brushes, standing intimately close...

  • Joan Miró: Birth of the World Joan Miró: Birth of the World

    20th century

    Finding the Poetry in Joan Miró: Birth of the World


    Three paragraphs. The Museum of Modern Art in New York City introduces the exhibition Joan Miró: Birth of the World, with three paragraphs. The first paragraph ends with the following sentence: “…Miró’s intense engagement with poetry, the creative process, and material experimentation inspired him to paint The...

  • Hilma af Klint in the Guggenheim Museum Hilma af Klint in the Guggenheim Museum


    Hilma af Klint in the Guggenheim Museum and the Rethinking of Abstract Art


    I avoided seeing the Hilma af Klint—Paintings for the Future exhibition in New York City for months because I did not like the abstract artwork the Guggenheim used to advertise it. I thought the shapes in the paintings were ordinary. And I did not feel the spirituality...

  • Protest at Andy Warhol From A to B and Back Again Protest at Andy Warhol From A to B and Back Again

    NYC Art Critic

    Protest at Andy Warhol From A to B and Back Again—with Sage


    An innocent visit to the Whitney Museum of American Art in the West Village of New York City on Sunday, December 9, turned into something more. The smell of burning sage was powerfully oppressive. The New York City fire department was called to restore order. The...

  • Delacroix at the Metropolitan Delacroix at the Metropolitan

    NYC Art Critic

    The Majestic Paintings of Eugène Delacroix at the Metropolitan Museum of Art


    The rooms were dimly lit and majestic, and the paintings of Eugène Delacroix were larger than life. The Metropolitan Museum presented these paintings in this environment, on the heels of its exhibition of Delacroix’s drawings. That exhibition is more intimate because the sketchbooks of Delacroix were...

To Top