Fortune-tellers: Art of Superstition

Magda Michalska 30 November 2016 min Read

St Andrew’s Day is not only a Scottish holiday. In Poland we have this old and pagan tradition of fortune-telling on the night of the 29th of November. We do magic tricks like pouring hot wax through a small hole in a door key or we try to peel an apple in one continuous go.
Anyway, these traditions inspired me to show you paintings which treat the same subject: fortune-telling!

A first tense encounter

Caravaggio, The Fortune teller, 1599, The Louvre
Caravaggio, The Fortune teller, 1599, The Louvre

Caravaggio was the guy who started the fashion of depicting fortune tellers. Many generations of Caravaggisti who followed into his footsteps of stark chiaroscuro contrasts and shady characters gave this topic a try. You can see a fortune teller woman who is trying to trick a young rich boy who is feeling very cool because he’s wearing a fancy hat. I love their exchange of gazes- when I look at them, I’m not sure anymore who’s gonna trick who in the end.

Second and much tenser encounter

Georges de la Tour, The Fortune-Teller, 1632-1635
Georges de la Tour, The Fortune-Teller, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1632-1635

Same scene, slightly altered, and just 30 years later (for painting at this time it’s not that many, trust me) by de la Tour  who was one of the French Caravaggisti. Here, however, the fancy boy is not feeling so self-confident anymore. I guess I wouldn’t either if I was surrounded by four women looking at me so intently. Look closely on the left bottom corner- boy’s money is not going to stay in his pocket any longer. Poor guy.

An encounter which leaves mixed feelings

Joshua Reynolds, The Gypsy Fortune Teller, 1777-1778
Joshua Reynolds, The Gypsy Fortune Teller, 1777-1778

Changing setting, now we are in a rococo garden and the fortune-teller is having a try on a lady with a small girl. Look at these three very different facial expressions: a girl is laughing, probably at the news that the gypsy has just pronounced. Her guardian, however, looks very concerned. What was the fortune told? We can only imagine.

An encounter with the viewer

Mikhail Vrubel, The Fortune Teller, 1895, Bakhrushin Theater Museum, Moscow, Russia
Mikhail Vrubel, The Fortune Teller, 1895, Bakhrushin Theater Museum, Moscow, Russia

The first beautiful portrait of a fortune teller I’m showing you. It’s a fascinating painting, as the brushwork, looking so anxious and rapid, brings us right into the middle of the mysterious world of this woman. Everything seems half-real, ephemeral and magic, and the direct gaze of the girl challenges us saying: Do you believe me? Vrubel’s technique made him to be associated with Symbolists and Art Nouveau, yet he didn’t want to be included in any of the general trends, he preferred to stay on his own.

No more encounters

Helena Sofia Schjerfbeck, The Fortune Teller (Woman in a Yellow Dress), 1926
Helena Sofia Schjerfbeck, The Fortune Teller (Woman in a Yellow Dress), 1926

And that’s an attempt on the same theme of a Finnish painter, Helena Sofia Schjerfbeck. As most Expressionists, she did many portraits, rather than group studies, because this way she was able to render the psychic of the sitters. This lady is rendered in a classic 3/4 approach (bust-like), yet a simplified drawing of her face in black and well-defined lines references the woodblock prints, a technique used also by the German expressionists. Her pensive and rather sad look introduce a gloomy atmosphere. Is it because she saw in her cards a misfortune coming up?



Republic of Austria v. Altmann: Gustav Klimt, Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer I, 1907, oil, silver, and gold on canvas, Neue Galerie, New York, NY, USA. Painting

Republic of Austria vs. Altmann: Klimt Goes to Court!

Adele Bloch-Bauer was a wealthy socialite from Austria. One day, her husband asked Gustav Klimt to paint her portrait as an anniversary gift. But...

Ruxi Rusu 11 November 2021

Saint Luke. Maerten van Heemskerck, St. Luke painting the Virgin, 1532, Frans Hals Museum, Haarlem, The Netherlands. Painting

Saint Luke: The Ultimate Holy Painter

Christianity has a saint for everything, literally everything. And on All Saint’s Day, it’s the time we remember Saint Luke. Not only is he one...

Jimena Escoto 1 November 2021


10 Most Beautiful Artistic Flower Arrangements for Spring

Winter passed so quickly this year. The situation is still weird, to say the least, in several countries around the world. However, Spring has always...

Errika Gerakiti 21 February 2021


Joseph Wright of Derby: Painting the Industrial Revolution

Joseph Wright of Derby is deemed as the first painter to capture the spirit of the Industrial Revolution. His paintings portray the zeitgeist of his...

Anastasia Manioudaki 11 December 2020